In Her Own League had a lot of elements that worked well and some that didn’t quite land for me. Reese and Emmett’s relationship mostly worked for me. They had a truly engaging and enjoyable dynamic. Great chemistry, fun banter.

Emmet had spent much of his life focused on providing his daughter with a stable, loving life. And then once she moved out, he gave everything to the team. When Reese enters his life, it feels meaningful for him to finally have someone who supports him in return. One of the book's strongest aspects is Emmet’s relationship with his daughter, Miller. Their father–daughter bond is truly the heart of the story and adds warmth and emotional depth throughout the novel.

Reese was portrayed as intelligent, determined, and deeply committed to her new role within the team. As the first female owner, she faces a lot of pressure, and every decision she makes is scrutinized by the public and even her employees. The tension created an interesting backdrop for her character, and I wish Tomforde had done it a bit more justice. At times, it felt too in the background, and I would have liked a stronger arc for Reese.

As much as I loved Reese and Emmet’s relationship, the pacing was something I struggled with. One moment, they seem to dislike each other, and the next, they are flirting heavily and moving toward instant attraction. Their romance would have benefited from a slower burn and more conflict or tension between them before things progressed.

Final Thoughts

In Her Own League has enjoyable moments, strong banter, and an amazingly heartfelt father-daughter relationship. However, the rushed pacing and underdeveloped potential in Reese’s storyline make it a weaker entry compared to other books in Liz’s catalog.

Buy on Amazon Kindle | Audible | Paperback | Bookshop.org